17 May Top 5 Trucking Insurance Agencies in Columbus, Ohio in 2025
If you’re a trucker or own a fleet in Columbus, choosing the right trucking insurance agency is key. A good agency helps you stay protected on the road, follow the rules, and save money.
Below are the top five agencies in 2025. Each offers strong coverage and great customer service.
-
Daylight Insurance Agency – Local, Trusted, and Reliable
Daylight Insurance Agency is a leading trucking insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio. They are known for providing custom insurance plans for truckers and owner-operators. Based in Hilliard, they work with many top insurance carriers to find the best policy for your needs.
Key Features:
- Over 20 coverage options (liability, cargo, rental, gap, and more)
- Help with federal and state filings
- Easy claims process
- Friendly, local service
Why Choose Daylight Insurance?
Daylight Insurance is not just another agency. They focus on educating clients, giving honest advice, and helping you understand your coverage. Whether you drive one truck or manage a fleet, Daylight gives you peace of mind on the road.
-
Charles Cain Group – Experts in Ohio Trucking Laws
Charles Cain Group has strong experience in trucking insurance. They understand DOT compliance and offer great coverage for truckers all over Ohio.
Coverage Includes:
- Auto liability
- Physical damage
- General and cargo liability
- Bobtail insurance
They are known for fast service and expert help in claims and compliance.
-
Wexford Insurance – Big Coverage, Small Business Service
Wexford Insurance is a full-service trucking insurance agency. They cover many types of trucking—from dry vans to hazmat haulers. Whether you’re just starting or have years on the road, Wexford has a plan for you.
Coverage Options:
- Motor truck cargo
- Bobtail and non-trucking
- Trailer interchange
- General liability
Wexford also offers safety tips and online support tools for clients.
-
Hummel Group – Trusted for Over 60 Years
The Hummel Group is one of the most experienced names in trucking insurance. They offer smart risk management and personalized service.
Specialized Coverage:
- Workers’ comp
- Property and liability
- Bobtail and trailer insurance
They have certified Transportation Risk Specialists (TRS) who guide you through every step.
-
The Insurance Store (TIS) – Tech-Savvy and Truck-Friendly
The Insurance Store is known for its digital tools. Their app, TIS24, lets you view policies and download documents anytime.
Top Services:
- Quick COI delivery
- Custom plans for many truck types
- Personal support with new tech features
Final Thoughts
Looking for the best trucking insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio? These five stand out for their service, coverage options, and trucking expertise.
For local, personalized help, Daylight Insurance Agency is a top choice. Protect your trucks, your drivers, and your future partner with the right agency today.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.